THE DEHYDRATION OF ETHANOL

THE DEHYDRATION OF ETHANOL This page looks at the mechanism for the acid catalysed dehydration of a simple primary alcohol like ethanol to give an alkene like ethene. This isn't as straightforward as the dehydration of a secondary or tertiary alcohol, and it is important that you read the page about the dehydration of propan-2-ol before you continue with this page. The dehydration of ethanol The facts Ethanol can be dehydrated to give ethene by heating it with an excess of concentrated sulphuric acid at about 170°C. Concentrated phosphoric(V) acid, H3PO4, can be used instead. The acids aren't written into the equation because they serve as catalysts. If you like, you could write, for example, "conc H2SO4" over the top of the arrow.
	Note:  There are many side reactions which go on at the same time. These aren't required by any current A' level syllabus.
The mechanism A problem! You will find two versions of the mechanism for the dehydration of primary alcohols on the web and in various textbooks. One of these is exactly the same as the mechanism for the reaction involving propan-2-ol and other secondary or tertiary alcohols (known technically as an E1 mechanism), but the other is different (known as an E2 mechanism). The more reliable sources give the E2 mechanism for the dehydration of primary alcohols including ethanol. I am going to treat this as the "correct" version. The correct version in full If you have read the page on the dehydration of propan-2-ol, you will know that it involves the formation of a carbocation (a carbonium ion). If ethanol used the same mechanism, you would get a primary carbocation formed, CH3CH2+, but this is much less stable than a secondary or tertiary carbocation. That would lead to a very high activation energy for the reaction.
	Note:  You will find a discussion about carbocations by following this link.
The alternative mechanism avoids the formation of the carbocation, and so avoids the high activation energy. We are going to discuss the mechanism using sulphuric acid. In the first stage, one of the lone pairs of electrons on the oxygen picks up a hydrogen ion from the sulphuric acid. The alcohol is said to be protonated. That is exactly the same as happens with propan-2-ol and the other secondary and tertiary alcohols. In the mechanism we have already looked at with propan-2-ol, the next thing to happen was loss of water to form a carbocation, followed by removal of a hydrogen ion from the carbocation and the formation of a double bond. In this case, instead of happening in two separate steps, this all happens at the same time in one smooth operation. By doing that, you avoid the formation of an unstable primary carbocation. No simplified version of this! I am not giving a simplified version of this mechanism just in terms of hydrogen ions. If you don't show something removing the hydrogen ion from the protonated alcohol, you are really missing an important feature of the reaction. The other mechanism that you might come across This is the mechanism that looks justs like the one involving propan-2-ol, and involves the formation of an unstable primary carbocation. This is the version that you would have found on Chemguide up to December 2012, and was originally included because it was the one wanted by one of the UK Exam Boards at the time I wrote the page in 2000. It is possible that your examiners may still want it. As far as I am aware, the only syllabus which I track which still asks this topic is IB, and one of their mark schemes gave the version below. If you need to know about this, you need to check what your examiners are currently expecting. Note for IB students: I contacted IB about this to find out exactly what they wanted, and received a prompt and helpful reply: "Although the IB syllabus does not identify different elimination mechanisms (E1 and E2 to give only the most common ones), it is generally assumed that teachers will teach their students the proper mechanism (as you do so) depending of the substrate. It is therefore questionable to have published a mark scheme with an E1 mechanism since the E2 mechanism was then the most probable. We apologize for the confusion. Nevertheless, during the marking process following the little syllabus guidance, examiners did allow the use of any one of the elimination mechanisms and thus, for example, did not penalize the use of an E1 mechanism for the dehydration reaction of a primary substrate/alcohol (this is of course not what we want to see as an answer)." Essentially they are saying that they expect you to have been taught the correct version of the mechanism (the first mechanism on this page), but that they will accept either version. I understand that there is no consistency in the versions which the various IB textbooks give on this either. If you aren't sure what to do, I suggest you talk to your teacher about it. The safest thing to do is to learn the correct version, of course - and if you intend to carry on with chemistry at a higher level, this is what you should do.